.

The Victorian egg industry has hit out at the RSPCA over a letter it sent to farmers urging a voluntary end to the practice of caged eggs.
A letter from RSPCA CEO Heather Neil, farmers were asked to end the conventional cage systems.
But Victorian Farmers Federation Egg Group President Tony Nesci said the letter was inappropriate.
“I think Heather Neil forgot she was actually talking to people who have experience with these systems and the welfare outcomes for these birds,” he said.
“We’re the ones who know that her push to ban cages is based on opinion, not facts.”
Ms Neil told farmers that “contemporary science… indicates that the welfare of hens is severely compromised in conventional cages” while in other systems any adverse welfare outcomes could be managed with good stockman skills.
However Mr Nesci said her comments were based on opinion, not fact.
“The RSPCA is running around making claims that hens suffer inside cages, but the truth is birds in cages suffer just 2 to 3 per cent mortality, compared to free range at 15 to 25 per cent,” Mr Nesci said.
“They claim that 50 to 60 per cent of the industry is free range when 70 per cent of the industry is caged.
“Their information doesn’t stack up and it is underhanded to create instability by circumventing the poultry welfare standards setting process.”
The letter left open an offer to discuss “a reasonable phase out timeframe” for conventional caged systems, after the RSPCA earlier this year threatened to boycott consultations to introduce a new poultry welfare standard if the national organisation representing egg farmers – Egg Farmers Australia – didn’t commit to a voluntary phase out.
“It’s like she thinks that our national body doesn’t know what farmers want, but our national body is there to represent our industry, and that’s who the RSPCA should be corresponding with, not farmers,” Mr Nesci said.
Mr Nesci said the egg industry was committed to improving its practices through the poultry welfare standard process.
“The RSPCA had all of last year to contribute to the process and flag the science they wanted looked at, just as we were given that opportunity through Egg Farmers Australia,” he said.
“They didn’t get the result they wanted because the science isn’t there.”

Comments are closed.

More News

Pakenham couple Lily and David Jack have proven that young love can last a lifetime as they celebrate 70 years of ...

The prayers of a young family have been answered by the work of Pakenham’s Irabina Autism Services. After their ...

Shrek the Musical Kambrya College students are performing Shrek the Musical Jr. The production is based on the Oscar-winning DreamWorks ...

A young Pakenham family with two autistic children has been left homeless after a fire tore through their home, destroying ...

After years of unexplained ill-health and agonising pain, Bunyip resident Elly Solomon has had to face some tough answers after ...

A man has been assaulted while withdrawing cash from an ATM on Main Street, Pakenham. Police report the victim was ...

Latest Sport

SOUTH EAST JUNIORS – FINALS REVIEW The finest teams in the South East Juniors did battle on the weekend with grand ...

ELLINBANK AND DISTRICT FOOTBALL LEAGUE REVIEW – ROUND 17 Poowong has broken its 16-game losing streak to start the EDFL season with ...

WEST GIPPSLAND FOOTBALL NETBALL COMPETITION REVIEW – ROUND 17 The inaugural WGFNC home and away season is set for a stunning crescendo ...